Rhinitis is a common illness in children. Of course, treatment for a runny nose is prescribed by a specialist after examining the child. If the baby has clear snot, then vasoconstrictor drops are prescribed. But if the color of the discharge is greenish, then antibiotic medications are needed.
The best and most effective among the existing drugs isofra and polydex. But what is the difference between them and how does one medicine differ from another?
Features of the drug isofra
Isofra is a drug that has an antibacterial effect, that is, it belongs to the group of antibiotics. Its composition is based on framecitin sulfate. As a rule, this remedy is prescribed for bacterial rhinitis, when the snot has an unpleasant odor and a greenish or brownish tint. It can be used for different age categories, including children. Thanks to its properties, Isofra copes well with sinusitis, pharyngitis and sinusitis.
The drug is available only in spray form. This is characterized by the fact that therapy in this form is better than in drops.
General
- Both products are produced pharmaceutically in France. The form of release of the drugs is also the same - a spray with a dispersing tip .
- Medicines belong to the group of antibiotics. They have the same indications for use. Combines the drugs and the almost complete absence of side effects, with the exception of rare skin reactions.
- The period of use of any of the products should not exceed 10 days.
- Isofra and Polydex sprays are approved for use in the treatment of young children.
- The cost of the drugs differs slightly; they are in the same price range.
Features of the drug Polydex
This medicine is complex, as it contains several active ingredients: neomycin, polymexine, dexamethasone, phenylephrine. Thanks to this, it can be used simultaneously as an antibiotic, as well as an antiallergic and vasoconstrictor. That is, in addition to destroying bacteria, the drug eliminates swelling and nasal congestion.
It contains two types of antibiotics, which makes the therapy even more effective. Available in two forms: spray and drops. But the drops do not contain a vasoconstrictor component. Thanks to this, drops can be used to treat ear infections in children.
Let's talk more about drugs
Isofra is a nasal antibiotic with local action. The main active ingredient is framycetin, which actively fights the runny nose of bacterial origin (“green snot”). Also, indications for the use of Isofra include complications of a runny nose - sinusitis, pharyngitis, sinusitis, etc.
Polydexa is a multi-directional drug containing several active substances: dexamethasone, polymyxin, neomycin. Due to this composition, the drug itself may belong to the class of antibiotics, vasoconstrictors and antihistamines at the same time. The drug can be produced in 2 different forms, and so different that they are used completely differently: the spray is used exclusively nasally, and drops can be used for the ears. In accordance with this, the medicine is most often used in ENT practice. It is worth noting the difference between the two pharmaceutical forms of Polydexa; the drops do not contain a vasoconstrictor substance, otherwise the composition is the same.
Contrary to popular belief, Polydexa and Isofra are not analogues of each other - they are 2 completely different medicines.
How are the drugs similar?
Isofra and Polydexa have few similarities, but they still exist, namely:
- The most important thing is that Isofra and Polydexa belong to the class of antibiotics, and as a rule, their duration of use should be no more than 10 days. It is not recommended to carry out treatment with such drugs for a long time, so as not to cause disruptions in the immune system.
- They are produced in the form of a spray, which facilitates the therapy process.
- The manufacturer of these medications is also common - this is the French company Laboratoires Bouchara-Recordati
- Their pricing policy is also almost the same.
In principle, these are all the similarities of these funds. What is their difference?
Indications
Polydexa or Isofra is prescribed for almost the same diseases.
Isofra:
- Rhinitis.
- Sinusitis.
- Rhinopharyngitis.
Polydexa:
- Also prescribed for rhinitis, it copes well with both chronic and acute illness.
- Sinusitis.
- Rhinopharyngitis.
What are the differences in the readings? The first drug can also be used as treatment or prevention of the inflammatory process that immediately arises after surgery.
How are the medications different?
Despite the same antimicrobial effect and release form, Isofra and Polydexa are completely different. Their difference is as follows:
- Compound. Medicines have different active substances in their composition. Based on this, polydex has a wider range of applications than isofra, since it has a rich composition
- Application area. If isofra treats only diseases of the nasopharynx, then polydexa can also treat inflammatory diseases of the ear
- Rules of application. Before using Polydex, the child should clear the green mucus from the nose. But isofru, on the contrary, is first dripped into an unclean nose, and only then washed with saline solution. This is necessary in order to better remove the remaining active ingredients. Also, before the injection itself, the Polydex medicine needs to be warmed in your hand. But Isofra does not require such manipulations, it is only important to shake the bottle
- Contraindications. Due to the fact that Polydexa contains two antibiotics, it is prohibited for use in children under 2.5 years of age. Isofra can be taken from one year of age. Therefore, isofra is better suited for very young children.
- Side effects. Isofra, unlike Polydexa, has fewer side effects
Polydexa
Polydexa is a drug that has an antibacterial, anti-inflammatory and vasoconstrictor effect. Available in spray form.
The drug contains four active components. , 2 antibiotics are neomycin and polymyxin B. As well as a substance with a vasoconstrictor effect - phenylephrine and a hormonal agent with anti-inflammatory and immunosuppressive effects - descamethasone.
Indications for use of the spray:
- Inflammation of the paranasal sinuses.
- Acute or chronic inflammation of the nasal mucosa.
- Rhinopharyngitis.
Polydex spray, due to its serious and complex composition, has a number of contraindications for use:
- Viral infections.
- Pathological processes in the kidneys, characterized by proteinuria.
- Suspicions of the presence of angle-closure glaucoma.
- Concurrent use of MAO inhibitors.
- The period of gestation and lactation.
- Children's age up to 2.5 years.
- Individual intolerance to components.
Polydexa contains substances that can give a positive result in a doping control.
The recommended period of treatment with the drug is 5-10 days.
How to choose the right product?
Which is better for isofra or polydex for sinusitis? When answering this question, you need to take into account the age and condition of the nasal passages and sinuses.
In case of a more complex course of the disease, Polydex will be more effective, but only if the patient is over 2.5 years old. It is important to know that advanced stages of sinusitis will not be cured only with Polydex Isophroy. Sprays are used only as auxiliary medications and should be used in combination with other medications and procedures.
For children who are prone to allergic reactions, Polydexa is better than Isofra, because it contains antihistamines. But due to the large number of active substances in polydex, this does not have a very good effect on the protective function of the child’s body. And although isofra does not have antiallergic components in its composition, it does not affect the immune system.
For an illness such as otitis media, Polydex will do without hesitation. After all, it is produced in the form of drops specifically for the treatment of this disease.
There are opinions that Polydexa or Isofra are the same medicine. Please note that polydexa and isofra are not structural analogues. Any decision in favor of one remedy or another must be made by a doctor. He will assess the little patient’s condition and prescribe the appropriate medicine. Only in this case can you avoid complications that may arise when you independently select a drug and treat the disease. Be healthy!
So which is better - Isofra or Polydex?
When you know what the features of both drugs are, let's see what are their differences and similarities.
Common features: Isofra and Polydexa
- Both drugs are supplied by a well-known French manufacturer, which is a guarantee of high quality products;
- Both drugs show high effectiveness in the fight against advanced rhinitis and sinusitis;
- They cost about the same;
- They eliminate almost the same groups of pathogenic microorganisms - they are used for green snot;
- Suitable for children, but of different ages;
- Both drugs can be used for no more than 10, and preferably 7 days.
Differences: Isofra and Polydex
- Isofra is a simple drug (it contains no components except framycetin), which has fewer side effects and contraindications, although the indications for its use are no different from those of Polydexa;
- Polydexa is a combination drug that not only fights infection through the presence of two antibiotics, but also eliminates the symptoms of rhinitis. However, it has many contraindications and side effects;
- The minimum age of the patient at which these drugs can be used. Polydex is prescribed for children after 2.5-3 years, but Isofra is prescribed for children after 1 year.
For a child, it is best to choose a simpler and safer option - Isofra. But if the doctor examined your child and believes that the disease is advanced, you should agree with the ENT specialist and start administering Polydex.
There is also a question: “Isofra or Polydex for sinusitis?” It is ambiguous and only a doctor can answer it better. If the case is severely advanced, then only Polydexa will cope, but if all is not lost, it is better not to complicate life for your nose and use Isofra - it is better tolerated by the body.
To summarize, let's say that Isofra and Polydexa are high-quality French drugs that are equally effective, but are used in different clinical situations. Only a doctor can express the most competent opinion about the advisability of using one of the remedies!
Source
Precautionary measures
Isofra and Polydexa are well tolerated. Side effects are rare and are associated with individual intolerance to the drug. Itching, burning, and swelling of the nasal passages usually occur. If such symptoms appear, you should immediately stop treatment and consult a doctor.
Polydexa is not prescribed for a long course (more than 10 days). Phenylephrine dries out the mucous membrane and is addictive.
Isofra and Polydexa are not prescribed during pregnancy and lactation. Drugs are not used if hypersensitivity to the components is detected.
Polydexa is not prescribed for the following conditions:
- severe kidney pathology;
- angle-closure glaucoma;
- with caution - with hypertension, coronary heart disease and hyperthyroidism.
Polydexa is prohibited for use in athletes. The drug contains components that can be detected during doping control.
Polydexa and Isofra differences
Often people who come to the pharmacy ask the question: “Which remedy for the treatment of sinusitis or rhinitis should I choose: Isofra spray or Polidexa? It seems that these are two identical medications, because their indications for use are similar.
It is not difficult for many to even make a choice in favor of one remedy or another, but in fact only an experienced specialist can say which drug is suitable for a particular person.
Therefore, today we will look at what are the differences between the drugs “Isofra” and “Polydex” and do they have any similarities?
Antibiotics for sinusitis
Headache, mucous and purulent discharge from the nose, decreased sense of smell, general weakness, malaise - these are all signs of an illness such as sinusitis. Simply put, this is sinusitis. This disease is treated with various methods, depending on what stage the disease is at. If the problem has been bothering the patient for a long time, then the patient is prescribed antibacterial agents.
Among such drugs are the following sprays: “Bioparox”, “Isofra”, “Polidexa”. All three medications must be prescribed strictly by an otolaryngologist; self-treatment with these medications is not allowed. Today we will talk about only two drugs: Isofra and Polydex sprays. The thing is that many people consider these funds interchangeable.
But now we’ll find out whether this is really so.
Similarity of medications
The drugs have few similarities. So, what is considered the same among them is that they both belong to the group of antibiotics. Another similarity is especially in use, because both drugs are available in the form of sprays.
And the last common feature of these medications is that both drugs cannot be used for more than 10 days, because they are antibiotics. Otherwise, a person’s immunity will simply be undermined, and his body will no longer be able to fight harmful microorganisms on its own.
This is where the similarity of these medications ends, and then there are only differences.
Differences
- Compound.
- Application area.
- The procedure for administering the medicine.
- Contraindications and side effects.
Dissimilarities in the composition of medications
What is the difference between Isofra and Polydex, if both drugs are often prescribed for the same diseases? The most important difference is the composition of the drugs. Thus, Isofra spray contains the main active ingredient - framycetin sulfate. It is thanks to this component that the medicine can be prescribed by otolaryngologists for the treatment of rhinitis, sinusitis, and acute nasopharyngitis.
The drug "Polydex" contains neomycin sulfate, polymyxin B sulfate and dexamethasone metasulfobenzoate. A trio of these components ensures an expansion of the spectrum of antibacterial action of the drug against most microorganisms that cause infectious and inflammatory diseases of the ENT organs.
Now, knowing the composition of the drugs, we can guess which one is preferable, Isofra or Polydex.
What is better: to use a drug with one active substance or a product with three components? Of course, if we compare the composition, the Polydex medication, in comparison with the Isofra spray, has a more pronounced anti-inflammatory effect, so from this point of view it is better to purchase it.
Difference in the order of drug administration
All readers of this article should know that any topical antibacterial agents should be prescribed only with the permission of a doctor. This rule was no exception in relation to the medications “Polydex” or “Isofra”.
For a child, such medications should be prescribed by a pediatrician, or best of all, by an otolaryngologist.
Therefore, after going to the pediatrician, it is advisable for mother and baby to see a specialist so that he can prescribe the right medication to treat problems with the respiratory organs.
What else is the difference between “Isofra” and “Polydex” - medications often prescribed by doctors for “complicated” runny noses in children? In addition to the composition, the dissimilarity between these two drugs can be observed in the order of their use.
So, before using Polydex spray, the nasal mucosa should be cleaned and then the medicine should be administered directly. And if the doctor prescribed the medication “Isofra”, then after cleansing the olfactory organ and injecting the product, you should then rinse your nose with sea water again. This is done in order to remove excess medication.
In addition, before using Polydex spray, you should hold it in your palms for a while so that the medication warms up slightly. In the case of the drug “Isofra”, such manipulation should not be carried out. Simply shake the bottle and inject the product into each nasal passage.
Application area
Which medication to choose: Isofra or Polydex? Which is better and more effective of these two drugs? If we are talking about a disease such as otitis media, then there is no point in thinking about it.
After all, the remedy “Isofra” does not at all imply the treatment of this disease. But the drug "Polidexa", on the contrary, is often used in the treatment of otitis media.
The fact is that this medication is available not only in the form of a spray, but also in the form of drops.
— Sinusitis, including sinusitis (under one condition: if the patient’s nasal septum is not damaged).
- Non-allergic chronic runny nose.
— Infectious rhinitis of a bacterial nature.
— Prevention and treatment of the nasal cavity after surgical intervention in the olfactory organ.
But at the same time, this medicine can be prescribed to people with a runny nose caused by exposure to allergens. But Isofra is not suitable for this case.
Therefore, it is stupid to answer questions about which drug is preferable - Isofra or Polydex? What is better to buy at the pharmacy? After all, everything depends on the patient’s diagnosis.
Source: https://kozhnye.ru/polideksa-i-izofra-otlichija.html
Differences between Isofra and Polydexa drugs
Polydexa and Isofra are not the same thing - these drugs have a number of important differences:
- Compound. Polydexa includes 2 antibiotics and an anti-inflammatory agent. Isofra - one antibiotic Framycetin;
- Pharmacological effects. In addition to its destructive effect on microbes, Polydexa reduces the severity of symptoms of inflammation - pain, swelling;
- Number of immune microbes. Fewer bacteria are affected by Isofra;
- Prescription for nursing mothers and pregnant women. Polydexa is prohibited during pregnancy, Isofra is not contraindicated (with the permission of the therapist);
- Assignment to a child. Polydexa with Phenylephedrine cannot be prescribed to a child under 2.5 years of age. There are no other age restrictions;
- Release forms. Polydexa is produced in 2 forms: ear drops and spray. Isofra is produced in drops.
Also, the differences between Isofra and Polydexa lie in the average market cost - Isofra is slightly cheaper, by 50-100 rubles.
