What is better “Ascoril” or “Prospan” and what to choose

Comparison of the effectiveness of Prospan and Ascoril expectorant

Ascoril expectorant is more effective than Prospan - this means that the ability of the medicinal substance to provide the maximum possible effect is different.
For example, if the therapeutic effect of Ascoril expectorant is more pronounced, then with Prospan it is impossible to achieve this effect even in large doses.

Also, the speed of therapy is an indicator of the speed of the therapeutic action; Askoril expectorant and Prospan are also different, as is bioavailability - the amount of a medicinal substance reaching the site of its action in the body. The higher the bioavailability, the less it will be lost during absorption and use by the body.

Lazolvan or prospan

Another analogue of prospan includes lazolvan, and it is a structural analogue of the above-mentioned drug ambroxol. Lazolvan is a well-promoted German brand, which is why its price is 4 times higher than the cost of ambroxol. But prospan is 160 rubles more expensive than lazolvan, and here the second one acts as a cheap analogue.

Lazolvan has six dosage forms: capsules, tablets, solution, lozenges, syrup and rhinospray.

Important! For children, only low doses of the drug are used. In syrup, this dose is 15 mg/5 ml (single dose 2.5 ml). The injection calculation is as follows: 10 mg/kg/day (up to 4 injections per day).

In the age category from 5 years, inhalations of Lazolvan with saline solution (1:1 dilution) are performed. One procedure requires 3 ml of lazolvan.

Prospan or Lazolvan – it’s up to the doctor and you to decide; perhaps the price of the drug will not suit you. Otherwise, you need to choose which composition, taking into account the auxiliary components, is best suited for a particular patient.

We recommend reading - instructions and analogues of Lazolvan.

Comparison of the safety of Prospan and Askoril expectorant

The safety of a drug includes many factors.

At the same time, in Prospan it is quite similar to Askoril expectorant. It is important where the drug is metabolized: drugs are excreted from the body either unchanged or in the form of products of their biochemical transformations. Metabolism occurs spontaneously, but most often involves major organs such as the liver, kidneys, lungs, skin, brain and others. When assessing metabolism in Prospan, as well as in Ascoril expectorant, we look at which organ is the metabolizing organ and how critical the effect on it is.

The risk-benefit ratio is when the prescription of a drug is undesirable, but justified under certain conditions and circumstances, with the obligatory observance of caution in use. At the same time, Prospan does not have any risks when used, just like Ascoril expectorant.

Also, when calculating safety, it is taken into account whether only allergic reactions occur or possible dysfunction of the main organs. In other matters, as well as the reversibility of the consequences of using Prospan and Ascoril expectorant.

Ambroxol or Prospan - which is better?

The active ingredient ambroxol can replace prospan at any age. For nonproductive coughs, it is used in tablets, syrup and solution for intramuscular and intravenous administration.

In addition to the mucolytic effect, ambroxol promotes the formation of surfactant, which is a kind of protection for the alveoli of the lungs. The drug perfectly thins thick, sticky mucus and normalizes bronchopulmonary secretion.

Ambroxol is used even in premature babies using injectable forms of the drug. Minimum doses of syrup start from 2.5 ml.

The product is much cheaper than prospan, which makes it accessible to all segments of the population. Nausea and intestinal upset are very rarely observed during use. Such reactions are more often observed in children under one year of age. Only a doctor should prescribe a cough remedy, taking into account all the details of the disease and the patient’s individual sensitivity to the composition of the medicine.

Patients often ask the question of what to choose: Prospan or Herbion, which will be more effective?

Gerbion is an analogue of Prospan and Eucabal in terms of therapeutic effect. It is also represented by a complex of medicinal herbs: aqueous extracts of primrose roots and common thyme, supplemented with levomenthol.

The drug has a pronounced anti-inflammatory and expectorant effect, dilutes viscous sputum.

In childhood, according to the instructions, herbion is used from the age of 4, although in practice pediatricians prescribe this drug from the age of two, of course, if the child is not prone to allergic reactions.

The cost of herbion is 300 rubles, it is 120 rubles cheaper than prospan. But here you should pay attention to the amount of syrup in herbion, it is 50 ml more.

Despite the safety of herbal remedies, there may still be an individual's sensitivity to any medicinal plant. Therefore, at the beginning of treatment, especially in pediatric practice, it is necessary to carefully monitor the child. First of all, allergic skin rashes or gastrointestinal upset may occur.

We recommend that you familiarize yourself with the list of analogues and instructions for Gerbion.

Only practical experience will show which means is best.

Comparison of addiction between Prospan and Askoril expectorant

Like safety, addiction also involves many factors that must be considered when evaluating a drug.

So, the totality of the values ​​of such parameters as “o syndrome” in Prospan is quite similar to the similar values ​​in Ascoril expectorant. Withdrawal syndrome is a pathological condition that occurs after the cessation of intake of addictive or dependent substances into the body. And resistance is understood as initial immunity to a drug; in this it differs from addiction, when immunity to a drug develops over a certain period of time. The presence of resistance can only be stated if an attempt has been made to increase the dose of the drug to the maximum possible. At the same time, Prospan’s “syndrome” values ​​are quite small, just like Askoril expectorant’s.

Prospan - instructions for use

Prospan is a herbal cough remedy that has a variety of antitussive properties.
The active substance of prospan is a dry extract of ivy leaves. This composition under the trade name “Prospan” is presented in the form of a solution, drops, syrup, lozenges, and effervescent tablets.

All forms of Prospan have mucolytic, secretolytic, antispasmodic effects and mild bronchodilator properties. The drug helps to liquefy mucus and remove it from the tracheobronchial tree.

The average price for prospan (Germany) in pharmacies is as follows:

• syrup 100 ml – 420 rubles;
• drops 20 ml – 320 rubles;
• oral solution 35 mg/5ml No. 21 – 520 rubles;
• lozenges and tablets – availability and price need to be clarified.

Effervescent tablets 65 mg sachets are available in 10 pieces per box. Lozenges for resorption are presented in blisters of 20 pieces, a dosage of 26 mg of active ingredient in each.

Having studied the price of the drug, the conclusion suggests itself: Prospan is not a cheap drug, and probably a potential buyer will look for cheap analogues.

Indications

Prospan is used for pathologies of the bronchopulmonary system, when objectively the patient has a cough, difficulty in sputum discharge, and the mucus has a thick and viscous consistency. This picture is most often observed with tracheitis, tracheobronchitis, bronchitis (including obstructive forms), and bronchial asthma.

The drug is not used in case of individual intolerance to the composition, including excipients. The syrup contains fructose, so this form is used with caution in diabetics. The drops contain alcohol, therefore, alcoholism and other contraindications to alcohol are a ban on the use of this form.

Adverse reactions

In rare cases, the following negative symptoms have been observed:

• diarrhea;
• nausea (in case of overdose);
• allergic rashes.

No other side effects were detected while taking Prospan. If you notice any of the above symptoms while using Prospan (syrup or other dosage form), consult your doctor to select an analogue.

Prospan is prescribed for a course of at least 7 days. All prescriptions are made only by a doctor, this also applies to course extensions. The instructions for use draw attention to the fact that in order to consolidate the therapeutic effect, Prospan must be taken for another three days after the cough and sputum disappear (when all signs of inflammation have passed).

Most often, prospan is prescribed in syrup. It is used from the first months of life. Up to 6 years old, the recommended dosage is 2.5 ml, from 6 to 14 years old - 5 ml, for everyone else it is suggested to increase the dose from 5 to 7.5 ml. The syrup is taken three times a day.

You can find detailed dosages for other forms in the official instructions for prospan.

A study of the drug did not show any dangerous properties that could affect the fetus. But, despite this, the manufacturer warns that pregnant women should only take the product under the strict supervision of a doctor.

Comparison of side effects of Prospan and Ascoril expectorant

Side effects or adverse events are any adverse medical event that occurs in a subject after administration of a drug.

Prospan has almost the same level of adverse events as Askoril expectoranta. They both have few side effects. This implies that the frequency of their occurrence is low, that is, the indicator of how many cases of an undesirable effect of treatment are possible and registered is low. The undesirable effect on the body, the strength of influence and the toxic effect of Prospan is similar to Ascoril expectorant: how quickly the body recovers after taking it and whether it recovers at all.

Gedelix or prospan

Prospan or Gedelix – which is better to choose? It should be noted that these funds are structural analogues, because Both contain dry ivy leaf extract. Gedelix is ​​available only in drops and syrup, while Prospan also has lozenges and effervescent tablets.

Gedelix and Prospan are used in infants from the first months of life. They are indicated for all diseases of the respiratory system, when it is necessary to remove “stuck” thick sputum.

Both products are produced in Germany, only their companies are different. The price of Gedelix is ​​less, about 70 rubles.

We recommend reading - instructions and analogues of Gedelix.

Gedelix syrup for children - scope of application of Gedelix, release forms, analogues

Instead of Gedelix, the pediatrician may prescribe a drug with a similar therapeutic effect, for example:

• It is represented by several drugs that are effective for cough. The basis of one is ivy extract, the second - plantain and mallow, the third - primrose and thyme. All these medications are prescribed to children over 2 years of age.
• It, like Gedelix, contains ivy extract, so it is in demand for dry coughs. This form is used from birth. Prospan is also available in drops, but they are prescribed no earlier than two years of age.

• The main component of this product is thyme extract. The drug is approved for use in children over 6 months of age.
• This drug, containing 20 mg of carbocysteine ​​per 1 milliliter, is prescribed for coughs in children over two years of age. Its analogues are syrups.

• This medicine is popular in the treatment of cough in children as it effectively moistens the cough and helps remove phlegm. A doctor can prescribe it from birth if there are reasons for this. The drug is also produced in a solution used both internally and for inhalation.
• Lazolvan syrup or solution. This medication, containing ambroxol hydrochloride, is used in pediatrics at any age, including premature infants. Instead, other medications with ambroxol can also be used, for example, Ambrobene, Medox, or.

• This preparation contains extracts from aloe, licorice, ginger, basil and other plants. The medicine is used in the treatment of children over 3 years of age.
• Syrup. In this medicine, guaifenesin and salbutamol are added to bromhexine. The drug is in demand not only for bronchitis, but also for barking cough caused by whooping cough or laryngitis. It is prescribed to children over one year old.
• Syrup. This drug includes two herbal components that help with wet cough with viscous secretions - extracts of thyme and ivy. The medicine is prescribed from 3 months, and Bronchipret drops are allowed to be used from 6 years.

In consultation with your doctor, the drug can be replaced with a drug with a similar therapeutic effect. Synonyms and analogues of Gedelix are common in pharmacy chains.

overslept

The drugs are full analogues. They are made on the basis of climbing ivy extract and have the same indications and side effects. They differ in manufacturer, dosage and composition of excipients.

When choosing which is better - Gedelix or Prospan, it is better to entrust the decision to a specialist. There is not much difference between them, but Prospan is more expensive.

Gerbion

The manufacturer of the product is a pharmaceutical company from Slovenia. The main ingredient is climbing ivy extract. Herbion is also an analogue and can be recommended as a replacement.

Deciding which is better - Gedelix or Gerbion is not easy: the products are identical.

Pectolvan ivy

Ukrainian natural product of plant origin. The active ingredient is ivy extract. It has a similar effect, but costs less. Before use, it is recommended to read the instructions for use.

In addition to ivy extract, it contains liquid extract of thyme herb. Recommended for adults and children from 3 months. Rarely leads to side effects. Produced in Germany. It is considered more powerful than Gedelix. It is prescribed based on the individual characteristics of the patient.

Gedelix for children

Sometimes the body cannot cope with an illness on its own, be it bronchitis, pharyngitis or a common cold. This problem is especially relevant for young children, because the child’s immune system is not as strong as that of adults.

For the same reason, it is important to use only natural drugs for treatment that will not cause additional harm to the baby’s body. Gedelix expectorant syrup is allowed to be taken by children of any age; the medicine is absolutely safe for both newborns and adolescents

When coughing, most patients also experience other unpleasant symptoms, such as fever or runny nose. To eliminate the problem, complex therapy is required, which involves the use of an effective multifunctional agent.

The main feature of the drug Gedelix is ​​the content of components of plant origin.

The mechanism of action of the medicine is due to the presence of an active substance - extract from ivy leaves, and additional ingredients enhance its effect.

This expectorant for children is a thick yellow liquid with a pleasant odor. 100 ml of syrup contains 0.8 g of ivy extract.

In antiquity, a decoction of its leaves was used for severe coughs, since the plant has a pronounced antibacterial effect. Ivy contains such important substances for the body as organic acids, vitamins A and E, resins, saponins and iodine.

They prevent the growth and reproduction of fungi, which promotes rapid recovery.

When Gedelix enters the patient’s stomach, the drug begins to be quickly absorbed into the blood. The drug activates the movement of bronchioles, due to which there is a movement of sputum to the large bronchi. When the latter expand, liquefaction and expectoration of mucus occurs.

The drug reaches maximum concentration in the blood an hour after administration. The syrup effectively helps relieve cough by removing phlegm from the lungs.

Due to its natural origin, the solution is well absorbed by the body and is much less likely to cause allergic reactions in case of overdose.

Doctors prescribe Gedelix for infectious viral diseases of the upper respiratory tract, which are accompanied by cough. Direct indications for the use of syrup are the following ailments: tracheobronchitis, bronchial asthma, bronchitis, bronchospasm, bronchiectasis. The drug is used to thin and remove mucus and helps quickly get rid of dry cough.

The product relaxes tense bronchial muscles, facilitating the breathing process. Gedelix not only relieves negative manifestations, but also fights the cause of the disease.

During therapy, improvement of the microflora of the respiratory organs is observed, which became possible due to the antibacterial and antifungal properties of the solution.

The drug has a complex effect on the body, thins thick mucus and eliminates the signs of a dry cough.

The drug contains several extracts, each of which is responsible for its own medicinal properties.

• mucolytic (thinning of sputum);
• expectorant (facilitates the removal of pathological secretions from the bronchi);
• antispasmodic (relieves spasms, allowing you to breathe freely).

In addition to the main effect, the components of the drug have a healing and antioxidant effect, which allows you to restore damaged lung cells after illness.

The substances in the drug help relieve inflammation, which reduces the risk of complications and the disease becoming chronic.

Saponins, which are contained in syrup, have a detrimental effect on bacteria and fungi, which are the main cause of pathologies of the respiratory system. After their destruction comes recovery. And flavonoids improve blood circulation, which helps get rid of harmful microorganisms. They also accelerate the removal of fluid from the body, which reduces temperature and improves well-being.

Indications for treatment with syrup arise from its medicinal properties.

• ARVI, acute respiratory infections, influenza;
• exacerbation of chronic bronchitis;
• tracheitis;
• cough with difficult sputum of unknown etiology.

The use of the drug for these diseases allows for the removal of pathological secretions from the lungs, which prevents the proliferation of bacteria in it. This helps alleviate the condition from the first days of treatment.

The price of Gedelix syrup in standard release form in Russia is 360-500 rubles. The price of Gedelix in drops in standard form ranges from 300 to 360 rubles.

In Ukraine, the described syrup for children 100 ml costs 115-140 hryvnia, and the price of drops is 80-115 hryvnia.

The use of drugs to facilitate the discharge of sputum is of greatest relevance in the treatment of acute and chronic infectious and inflammatory diseases of the bronchi. Herbal medicines are of particular value. Not inferior in effectiveness to artificial expectorants, Gedelix and Prospan can achieve significant relief from bronchial obstruction.

Compound

Both drugs contain ivy leaf extract. The differences between Gedelix and Prospan lie in their manufacturer. Both drugs are produced in Germany, but the first is a product of the Meuselbach company, and the second of the Engelhard company.

Mechanism of action

It was previously thought that ivy leaf extract irritated the stomach lining by stimulating the vagus nerve. Since the same nerve regulates the tone and function of the bronchi, impulses from the stomach also spread to the respiratory tract, which leads to an increase in the production of watery sputum, dilation of the bronchi, and accelerated movement of sputum through the bronchi and trachea.

Of course, this theory of the effects of these drugs on the body is partially correct. But recent studies have established that Prospan and Gedelix indirectly increase the effect of adrenaline on the bronchial wall. This is what causes their expansion and increases the effectiveness of the simultaneous use of inhaled adrenergic agonists (Salbutamol, Fenoterol, etc.).

Indications

Since the composition of both drugs is the same, their indications, contraindications and side effects are the same.

Indications for use of Prospan and Gedelix:

• Infectious and inflammatory processes of the respiratory tract, accompanied by the formation of difficult to separate sputum (acute and chronic bronchitis, tracheitis, pneumonia);
• Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in the acute stage is a disease characterized by a gradual irreversible decrease in the lumen of the bronchi. Most often associated with smoking, frequent infectious diseases of the respiratory system, and inhalation of industrial dust.

Contraindications